30 Comments
User's avatar
Coequal's avatar

These universities are basically doing the same jury nullification thing as in the OJ Simpson trial. They know that they're breaking the law, but they think the law is unjust. The worst thing is that they're so dishonest about it, fooling naive outsiders into thinking that these skewed admissions result are actually based on merit. I don't care if some universities treat certain ethnic groups or athletes or children of influential people with favoritism, as long as they honestly and transparently show all their selection criteria that produced those results.

Epaminondas's avatar

Only people who are clueless or ideologically captured would believe that these skewed admissions are based on merit.

The evidence is overwhelming that race is being used as a selection criteria, and the average person is not as dumb as the admissions committees would like to believe. It's why the Supreme Court decision to strike down affirmative action was viewed favorably by a large majority that cut across every race and ethnicity.

barnabus's avatar

Universities are legally to be seen as individual people. They can't jury nullify. Juries can jury nullify because they are representative samples of "We, The People". Magna Carta and all that.

Commenter's avatar

Why do you think Asian students have been outperforming White students in the West during the last half-century, whereas Whites led the pack civilizationally and intellectually for several centuries before that (since the renaissance or certainly the enlightenment)? Usually modern circumstances can be predicted looking at the past, but this is surprising to me. If a genetic advantage propelled Europeans to the front in the last half millennium, what explains our relative underperformance in the last 50 years? And if one claims environmental or cultural factors make the difference, then where did the more innovative Western culture come from in the first place if not the Western collective personality? Moreover, what are the odds that someone else would be better than you in navigating your own culture and institutions? I wish there were more in-depth research into this topic, but of course it is wishful thinking given the thorniness of the subject.

RenOS's avatar

Asians have arguably outperformed europeans for the majority of recorded history in terms of development and technology, though. IMO it's underappreciated how likely it is for a culture to get stuck in a local equilibrium and stop improving, despite otherwise fulfilling all requirements for further development.

Note that europeans probably also benefitted greatly from the presence of Jews, which significantly outperform both europeans and asians. The possibility of course greatly enrages the white supremacists, but an alternative history of europe without jews might look a lot less impressive.

There is an argument that there are also other important qualities in addition to IQ that europeans outperform asians on, but even assuming they don't, history is random enough and susceptible to effects from single "great" persons and groups that the moderate IQ advantage that asians enjoy IMO does not disagree with history as it happened.

barnabus's avatar

Chinese had, what one would call "qualitatively bad governance" over a half millenium, from say 1430 to 1979. Basically, their geographic isolation made tolerating "qualitatively bad governance" easier, since they didn't have to compete with the best governed countries. Once they were out of that loop, they started overperforming. With the Japanese, they went out of the loop in the late 1800s, with South Koreans, in the 1950s.

RenOS's avatar

That's the thing, I'm not sure I'd even call it bad, certainly not all of it. The late Ming dynasty got pretty awful, yes, but large parts of the Qing were perfectly fine by historical standards, arguably even good - just not good *enough* to keep up with the pace of european development. They expanded their main territory and re-developed the tributary system.

barnabus's avatar

Yep, but that's the thing about not being good enough. In an open market, your company would be killed over that. But if you are isolated, you are fine. That's why I put the qualifier "qualitatively" before put down of "bad governance". Actually, I should have commented directly onto Commenter, lol

Mallard's avatar

It's hard to credit Jews for the rise of Europe relative to East Asia. Jews were able to contribute little economically until Emancipation, which mostly took place well after the start of the Enlightenment, and largely after the start and spread of the Industrial Revolution: https://www.cremieux.xyz/i/128153947/ashkenazi-jews. Jews thus accelerated growth after the Enlightenment, but don't explain why it emerged in Europe, rather than East Asia.

Coequal's avatar

I would guess that East Asians have higher average IQ than Europeans, but that Europeans have much fatter tails at either end of the distribution, enabling their outliers to drive more innovation than their Asian counterparts through most of recent history.

Commenter's avatar

I have often heard people make this claim but I’ve never seen the study or article or whatever that it comes from. I hate to be that guy, but what’s the source?

Coequal's avatar

I don't know of any good studies on this. I'm just basing my guess on my personal observations. White people are overrepresented among Nobel laureates, great men in history, artistic geniuses, the movers and shakers of science, etc., while East Asians are underrepresented in proportion to their population (even though they outnumber white people today and throughout recorded history). At the same time, the proportion of white people who are violent criminals, addicts, homeless is also much bigger than that same proportion of East Asians. East Asians in the US (and other countries) do much better in school than whites up through graduate school, but then whites catch up and overtake them when it comes to tenured faculty positions, political office, law firm and consulting firm partners, Fortune 500 leadership and officers, etc. I don't think cultural differences explain all of this gap, since it applies both to naive East Asians as well as those who grew up in western countries.

Commenter's avatar

You and Barnabus both make good points. FYI my original response got hidden for whatever reason. Not sure why, since I don’t think I wrote anything mean-spirited. I think you can still see it if you expand the “1 reply hidden” tab.

Marvin's avatar

Because educational attainment ≠ civilizational attainment. There are many more personality traits involved.

Ebenezer's avatar

Cofnas himself suggested that if you move to a totally race-blind regime, the number of black professors is liable to drop to an incredibly low level which undermine's black peoples' faith in the system. Maybe we can reach a compromise with some sort of limited quota system, with merit-based admission within each quota.

TheresaK's avatar

The funny thing is that MAGA Republicans turn out to not like the fact that Asians are now dominating college admissions, so you're probably going to have to have a similar quota to admit more white kids. And now we arrive back at Harvard's actual admissions policy before the SCOTUS ruling.

Peter Davis's avatar

In New Zealand a special quota system for Maori and Pacific student admissions to medical school has long been accepted - by the profession, by the student bodies, and by most major political tendencies. They have to meet a basic academic cut-off. There is a broad acceptance that Maori and Pacific patients - who make up about a fifth of the population - will open up more and do better when accessing doctors of their own ethnicity. There is also a move away from solely relying on exam grades for admission with greater emphasis on other qualities and criteria, as long as these are underpinned by high academic achievement.

TheresaK's avatar

Have you been paying much attention to what Republicans have been saying about Asian academic achievement lately? Apparently now that Asians are taking more top spots at universities, they don't like that much and want to restrict Asian immigration on the grounds that they work too hard.

Eugine Nier's avatar

I think that's mostly just a few Woke Right morons.

DeepLeftAnalysis🔸's avatar

I thoroughly disagree with the premise that affirmative action justifies a war against academia. In the same way, police brutality would not justify defunding the police.

Cremieux's avatar

I'm not calling for a war against academia, I'm calling for punishing institutions that allow their staff to break the law. The faculty are less-often at fault here.

DeepLeftAnalysis🔸's avatar

To be more specific: leftists say that when cops engage in police brutality, you should defund the entire institution. An appropriate and targeted response would actually be to arrest the admissions officers.

Thomas's avatar

I'm surprised that in all the talk of whites and Asians you've left out the group that most disproportionately does well and has the longest and strongest history of being discriminated against in university admissions for doing too well

Mallard's avatar

That group usually isn't specified on application forms, so there's less available data. In the case of Columbia, for which hacked data are available, surname analysis indicates that discrimination against Jews doesn't significantly differ from discrimination against other Whites: https://x.com/zagrebbi/status/2036087834650583466.

Interestingly, as noted there, in Columbia, South Asians are significantly more discriminated against than Whites and East Asians.

Jewish representation in Columbia has fallen faster than White representation, though (https://x.com/zagrebbi/status/2033780872097227021), and the decline in Jewish representation relative to the decline in non-Jewish White representation has been similar at Yale, and even larger at Harvard, where a number of non-discrimination explanation are ruled out: https://harvardjewishalumni.org/jewish-enrollment-at-harvard/.

Notably, Harvard has been one of the universities that engaged in the most blatant discrimination, in recent years, with the Black share of admissions actually being larger than the Black share of the population, even after Supreme Court ruling: https://x.com/cremieuxrecueil/status/1834042752373252393.

Nick Walker's avatar

The most effective step would be to prosecute and jail some admissions officers, deans, etc. The rest would adjust their virtuous principles very quickly.